(Although I will put the worst spoilers in white text just for the sake of propriety.). The job of the Harry Potter brain trust begins when Rowling's creative process ends. After 17 years of torture, I think Harry deserves a normal life with a family, don’t you? When I heard there was going to be a Harry Potter play I was excited yet sad at the same time. WARNING: this article contains SPOILERS for Harry Potter and the Cursed Child. That was the perfect place to bring the books to a close. Why wouldn’t Harry’s perfect ending be seeing his children moving on to the place he loved first and best? Subreddit dedicated to J.K. Rowling's Pottermore. That year saw the release of the sixth Harry Potter ... up the whole mess with the headline “ Final Harry Potter Book Blasted For Containing Spoilers. I couldn't find a way to talk about it without spoilers. I really disagree. I really liked the lost in the woods sequence. Although, Rowling didn’t say it directly, they all pulled together and fought against evil. A subreddit for the fans of the show Parks and Recreation. While all this interesting stuff is happening, we’re sitting around watching Harry try to figure out what to do next in the tent, since he doesn’t have a bleeding clue where the H’s are. Have you SEEN The Young Visiters? I was disappointed that his complexity was all boiled into a series of memories in a bowl. It was as if after 598 pages of an emotional roller coaster, we drift to the end. Please! Sigh again. What did he do to you? Discussion of the show, pictures from the show and anything else Parks and Recreation-related. SILBER LININGS: Who’s a good boy? Don’t get me wrong, I want the trio and all to live Happily Ever After, I wanted Harry and Ginny to have all those red-haired babies, etc. I missed Hogwarts incredibly, and wanted nothing more than the trio to stop hopping all over the place and Do Something! There's not a single witch or wizard who went bad who wasn't in r/HarryPotterMemes. Obviously, that didn’t happen with book 6 and I thought I was safe with this one as well. This is a subreddit dedicated to Marvel Comics, its publications and hundreds of characters. ... Posts on Reddit, Tumblr, and Twitter gave away all of the secrets by Friday. While the promised “bloodbath” was delivered, with many heartbreaking and shocking deaths, (the ones in the first 20 pages let us know this is no kiddie picnic) every bad character was redeemed: Snape, of course (could anyone have ever doubted his true allegiance? It was a great ride and a fun read. I loved the book, but did feel that it was overly long- after the blockbuster opening it crawled to a halt… Yes, it was anticlimactic, compared to the burly-brawl fight scenes that preceeded it, but remember… bourgeois means “middle class”, and the vast readership of the Potter tales are not wizards or witches… they’re middle class people. Maybe had the story continued after the books or against opponents other than … The only things she felt she needed to convey were that Voldemort was really dead this time, that Harry was happy, that life goes on, and that all is well. The sword of Gryffindor appears from the Sorting Hat to any heroic Gryffindor in need. I didn’t just fall in love with the Trio, I fell in love with everybody. Critique of Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows below the fold. Proceed at your own risk. (Here’s one that truly annoyed me: Ted Tonks is called a muggle in OOTP, but suddenly he’s a muggle-born wizard in DH?) I have kids. A helpful place for anyone getting married! Fred dies — what effect does that have on the rest of the family? From movies, theme parks, games, music, shopping, and more, find your MAGIC with r/Disney! All that has certainly damaged him. Luna's mother was accidentally killed while experimenting with a spell that she created when Luna was nine years old. Harry seems to have come through his ordeal unscathed, according to the epilogue. And why should Hagrid die? I envisioned it being through the use of the Deathly Hallows as this book progressed. I predict that Rowling WILL return to this world eventually. Share it wisely. Spoilers ahead. One of my biggest gripes with Rowling’s writing style is that she writes these plots that rush head-long into the future, barreling along at 90 mph and then, in the last chapter, she has Dumbledore sit down and explain everything that happened. While Potter won my heart over fully, Tolkien is still my favorite. OK Rosefire, I didn’t really mean “epilouge”, but I do think there would ba a good book to be had from the aftermath. All great heroes must go to the mountain, or the underworld, and Harry Potter is no exception. He was driven by his thirst for normalcy, a thirst every bit as strong as Voldemort’s for power and domination. From about the third book on, all Harry ever wanted was a normal life and a family. Brilliant! On the one hand it’s as close to happy ever after as we might get. Do not read this post if you do not want spoilers about HARRY POTTER AND THE DEATHLY HALLOWS! The coda was sweet, but like most of you, I wish it had been just a bit longer and included more of a sense of aftermath. My daughter was starting to lose steam in reading the book until I hinted that Mrs. Weasley and Bellatrix were in a scene together; she asked if Mrs. Weasley gets killed, I wouldn’t tell her and that got her going again! m. Edgar Wright should do HP7. get the fuck off this page if you support him. One has to wonder what “loose ends” MrsH would have been able to gloss over. Does he take his NEWTs? In the case of Deathly Hallows , that happened on Jan. 11, 2007, when Rowling (whose name, let it be said for now and all time, rhymes with bowling and not howling ) wrote the very last word of the Harry Potter saga in a suite at the Balmoral hotel in Edinburgh. Bravo1 to JK I say… Rowling has succeeded on every level. Oh and to MrsH, Tonks refers to her father as muggle-born in OotP, not as a muggle. Dobby who basically shows up, says, “Harry Potter, I’m here to save yo–arrrrgh!” Reminded me of Groundskeeper Willie trying to save everyone in the Simpsons’ Treehouse of Horrors, “I’m not very good at this!” Tonks and Lupin die — what effect does that have on their son? A place to get support and advice dealing with mean, nasty, toxic, and/or abusive MILs and moms. Also, Kingsley was appointed Ministry of Magic at the end…. Be sorted, earn house points, take classes with our fine Hogwarts staff, debate which actor portrayed Dumbledore the best, and finally get some closure for your Post-Potter … ), Kreacher, Dudley, the Malfoys, Pettigrew. Hmmm… I bet I won’t think it’s drawn out either. Be sorted, earn house points, take classes with our fine Hogwarts staff, debate which actor portrayed Dumbledore the best, and finally get some closure for your Post-Potter Depression. I am serious! All were saved by love of one kind or another– the Malfoys as wretched as they were, had real love — Narcissa and Lucious love Draco and thus are spared the final holocaust. I am 29, I am a total sarcastic art snob … and I freaking loooved the ending!! Get ideas on etiquette, invitations, themes, styles, or anything wedding-related. I will do my best not to give any spoilers at all, but I will make some very generalized statements and suggestions. This reference set off the alarm bells. Are you kidding me? Warning: This ranking may contain spoilers for the entire Harry Potter series. A new discovery from Reddit user Only_A_Friend definitely fits into the latter, burying the world of Harry Potter into an innocuous part of the game. The epilogue was overly sappy, and blandly written compared to the rest of the book. The 10 goodest dogs in comics, Soaring Penguin announces Tobias Taitt autobio BLACK BASTARD to join 2021 slate, Incoming Pet Patrol! But, as several others have said already, the ending left some to be desired. Email. I feel like it would have allowed the readers a chance to actually grieve for the fallen. I also realized a long time ago that Harry couldn’t really be killed off by JKR, but it seemed clear after HBP that he would have to somehow sacrifice himself and be brought back. I think the ending of the book was perfect. I don’t think anything thing else need to be explained. ‘Harry Potter and the Cursed Child’ Spoilers: Here is the Plot of J.K. Rowling's New Book. Harry Potter author J.K. Rowling has asked fans not to reveal details of her new West End play for eight weeks so as not to spoil the plot for others. As I had planned, I purchased HPaTDH at midnight, and stayed up until 4 am reading it. reminder this blog is pro human rights, and by extension anti trump. Harry Potter: Hogwarts Mystery. I really disagree. And one about the Next Generation: Salazar Slytherin still looms large, apparently, selfishness and evilish ambition are part of human nature. My husband is convinced that Harry is now the Minister of Magic, esp after Dumbledore’s assertion that power is best used by those who don’t seek it, yet who accept it when it is thrust upon them. It was such an excellent scene though as Neville comes up as the hero but part of me said “Wait! The regular YTMND's still work, and I honestly don't care for Harry Potter. Just my two cents – maybe I’m older than the average reader here (42) and while I agree the epilogue was different in style than the rest of the books, I have to tell you as a father of 5 – a happy family with healthy children is the best possible ending in the world-trust me on this (bourgeoisie? . Yes, I looked it up. We seek posts from users who have specific and personal relationship quandaries that other redditors can help them try to solve. Reddit's Doctor Who Fan Community - News, Discussion, Artwork and Fan Creations! Books, films, and other media Philosopher's Stone Chamber of Secrets Prisoner of Azkaban Goblet of Fire … This subreddit is just for discussions/questions about the books by JK Rowling. And the redemption of Kreacher felt real and welcome. :-D. My least favourite of the series, by far. My tiny gripe, if you can call it that, is the final chapter, the one written 10 years ago or such. I for one would much rather have David Yates stay on for the rest of the films. It’s the height of callous indifference to finish these characters stories in this manner. I really wished Rowling had paid more attention to Fred’s death. As she witnessed her mother's death, she was able to see Thestrals, the magical skeletal horses that led the Hogwarts carriages, from that point onward. After 17 years of torture, I think Harry deserves a normal life with a family, don’t you? I just did not like how oblivious Hagrid was to the danger he would put Harry et. The player creates a character and follows the story of a student at Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry, and throughout the game will have to make certain choices which determine the path their character will be placed on, including the kind of relationships they build with other characters. RE: the bourgeois ending. HA! Now the inevitable comparisons will begin, but as I missed Tolkien and Dickenson the first go round (too young), I am glad to have this literary eveny happen in my reading lifetime. NO JOKES. Hermione has always been my favorite character, but there is something about a boy-girl friendship or a brother and a sister that has always just gotten to me (see Ender’s Game). (Especially about Cuaron!). He’s already suffered so much. I think that would have made his final march to the forest even more poignant. Ron’s perfidy was as if Sam had suddenly deserted Frodo on the banks of the Ephel Duin. The idea of Harry and Hermione off doing their thing is just too good. Not all can stand up to the pressure. And as for the epilogue — what happened to tying up the loose plot ends? Nosleep is a subreddit for realistic horror stories. Family-friendly pet comics on the way. And that’s something all of us Potter fans can really do in life. Along with the story told through each chapter, they have the opportunity to achieve rewards by learning spells and potions.Th… An American TV show about a single mother and her daughter. Pokémon GO The blanked out word in the title of this post was “Redemption.” I wrote earlier about the Christian themes of the Harry Potter books, and thankfully, Rowling stuck with the Tolkien model rather than the Lewis model: the faith in the Potter-verse is always implicit. Man, what a crappy ending that would be. There’s nothing magical about it, but to me, the people who get up and go to work, day after day — because they love others — are the real heroes in life. Harry has been damaged by so much leading up to the final battle with Voldemort. So much for that idea. Fred’s death did hit me the hardest, and Harry’s digging Dobby’s grave was a wonderful/sad/touching moment, as was Snape’s “Look me in the eyes”, after his pensieve revelations that line meant so much more. It is not affiliated with Marvel Entertainment, LLC and is an unofficial community operated by dedicated fans. Writing Prompts. You only get one. Welcome to r/HarryPotter, the place where fans from around the world can meet and discuss everything in the Harry Potter universe! You're a writer and you just want to flex those muscles? The creator has a sick sense of humor Not that i care either way. But more important to me was how the wizarding world pulled itself back together directly afterwards. If you see a prompt you like, simply write a short story based on it. I thought that sounded doubtful and I doubt Rowling will stay away from the Potterverse, although I expect a very long gap in publication. I have no quibble with the ending. In particular, Harry’s long lonely journey with Hermione is one of the most touching adventures I have ever read: desperate and isolated. Another scene that resonated with me was when Harry was speaking with Dumbledore at the end. But nothing’s perfect! Heidi MacDonald is the editor-in-chief of The Beat and an award winning author and editor. I think Rowling was perhaps writing for the youngest end of her demo: I imagine kids will love the epilogue. That’s not his character people! A subreddit for fans of the popular hit TV sitcom, Friends. Sigh. The whole section with Dobby was extremely touching. I swear, if they leave the Molly/Bellatrix scene out of the final movie I will never buy another WB product again. His whole childhood and adolesence was strewn with deprivation and loss. Tumblr. **makes sigil to ward off poxy-stinky Lucascurse**. About the death of Fred, she didnt need to expand on it since Fred was only important because of his interaction with the main characters. Any other book would just be anti-climatic. The death of Snape and the chapter “The Prince’s Tale” — although much had been deduced by faithful readers — was still stunning and touching in its humanity and well it fit in with the overall mythology, especially the dying words “Look…at…me…”. But… I feel satisfied, and happy. That’s the exact opposite of what I’d call Rowling’s writing. Harry Potter book spoilers ahead! Throw Tiara in closet. About the Harry Potter play (No spoilers) Before you proceed through this post: I'm writing this 2 days after seeing Harry Potter and the Cursed Child at the Curran theater in San Francisco. I found some good HP fan footage from over the weekend…Wanted to share: http://www.maximonline.com/video/index.aspx?filekey=3054&src=tst25. HE’S your scathed hero. I hated the sceanes with Aunt Marge and on the Night Bus. As if. 5 books hating him, 1 book hating/pitying him, and a final book… ignoring him. As for what Hagrid did to me…. Still, Tolkien’s appendices take you back in time and forward to show that not everyone retires to a comfortable fireplace after heroic journeying. The loss of Fred was the hardest for me to take, but at least he went out laughing. Be sorted, earn house points, take classes with our fine Hogwarts staff, debate which actor portrayed Dumbledore the best, and finally get some closure for your Post-Potter … And I’m just left feeling so… unsatisfied. Hidden cave, no visible boat, zombies, deadly drink. This is a moderated subreddit. Where’d he get the sword?”. NO JOKES. Part of me wanted to attribute the emptiness I felt as reader’s fatigue, but upon further reflection, I think it’s the epilogue. Soooo glad that the novel ended at Hogwarts. Spoilers ahead. al. Compare and contrast: If you have not finished The Cursed Child yet then stop reading now. (This is full of spoilers. If Harry is indeed the MoM, it would be entirely fitting that, at the end of the book, he was focused not on his position but on being there for his kids at an important moment in their lives. Did anyone else read the final confrontation between Voldemort and Harry and get reminded of the final confrontation between Westley and Prince Humperdinck in “The Princess Bride”? The only two significant deaths, Lupin and Snape, are so rushed that they lost most of their effect. The 10 goodest dogs in…, DC ADVANCE ROUND-UP: Taylor & Redondo’s NIGHTWING #78 breathes new life…, The Marvel Rundown: The X-kids are alright in CHILDREN OF THE…. A subreddit to discuss the new installations in the Harry Potter Universe, Fantastic Beasts and Where To Find Them! “I’m frankly sorry I spent the money buying all three editions of this book.”, One plot hole I wish was taken up was how Neville ended up getting the sword of Gryffindor if the goblin had run off with it at Gringotts. Snape’s love for Lily brought tears to my eyes…, Oh, btw, maybe I am stupid, but…how does exactly Voldemort die? Overall – excellent – now lets have a real epilogue, of say 600 pages – Harry Potter and the Aftermath. Someone Imperius Jo into writing another epilogue about the months, not years, that follow!! For lightness we would have the reconstrction of Hogwarts to deal with (that could actually be fun). what i’m trying to say is that rowling’s ending for the book is both touching, realistic (in its own internally consistent way) and just the right touch, leaving much of these answers to our imagination rather than spelling them out for us. While Ms. Rowling has said she won’t be writing any more Potter books, I would love to see some novels about some of the secondary and tertiary characters, especially the ones who had the most happen to them in this book. Either 2 things have happened: 1. Afterall, he was a character that I’m sure many readers loved. re: Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone (spoilers) Posted by LSUSUPERSTAR on 10/29/16 at 9:11 am to dallastiger55 If you read the books, TPOA was when Rowling started to let them change the story. “BOLD”???? Alfonso Cuaron? Email. I think it's important to get one thing straight right off the bat: I am a fan of the Harry Potter series. For me, he is the most real, compelling character in the series. I would have preferred another chapter about the aftermath before the Happily Ever After. (It’s magic.). While the wizards and witches at Hogwarts are heroic, they’re not real people, but real people can be heroic, just by living their lives. The shortest Harry Potter film is Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 2 (2011) at 2 hours and 10 minutes. I think it's important to get one thing straight right off the bat: I am a fan of the Harry Potter series. guy drives past barnes and nobles and ruins the ending of a newly released Harry Potter book. On the other, it seemed needlessly bourgeois. AskWomen: A subreddit dedicated to asking women questions about their thoughts, lives, and experiences; providing a place where all women can comfortably and candidly share their responses in a non-judgmental space. I could really have done iwht a little less sitting around in the tent and a little more on the EFFECTS of what happens. One thing: Draco’s kid will be named “Scorpius”??!?! I enjoyed the book, but wow, that epilogue – it reminded me of For Better or For Worse, where in spite of everything epic that’s happened and all the people they’ve met, the main characters end married to their childhood sweethearts and happily domestic with kids. Be sorted, earn house points, take classes with our fine Hogwarts staff, debate which actor portrayed Dumbledore the best, and finally get some closure for your Post-Potter Depression. Wouldn’t Prof. Umbridge be delighted. Does Harry end up taking his 7th year afterwards, or does he get some honorary degree? Holy yes, I couldn’t agree more! I WANT A SNAPE BOOK! Some people have said that this part of the book is needlessly drawn out, but to me it was entirely necessary to see Harry stripped of almost everything, cut off from all news or succor, truly on his own. Emilianbucks, I’m on your side. “Go ask the spiders, here watch this giant for me…” , and in the middle of a battle to the death, friends dying left and right, he wants to protect rampaging spiders that are out to kill his friends. I was right all along about Snape (not a hrd thing to guess, really) and I loved his final line too, but I do wish somehow we’d had more of him. ask almost anyone who has been through some sort of madly horrific experience, like HP’s life to this point, and they’ll usually tell you that all they want is to go home and live a nice, quiet life, without all the fuss. Really, except for Dobby’s, all the deaths in DH were glazed over. Having quit at book three (but lovin’ the movies), this review makes me want to read the rest. It’s fitting. He lost his parents, Sirius his Godfather, his owl Hedwig, Dobby, and so many others that sacrificed for his cause. I admit, I was a little disappointed that Harry seemed to have triumphed with no real loss or sacrifice. And one about the Founding Wizards. Does he end up becoming an Auror? So when he saw the last movie, he was confused, so he created his own story in his head. I didn’t even register that Lupin and Tonks had been killed till he shows up with Harry’s parents. How did he feel afterwards? The Easter egg, which is … I read it all day yesterday (Arthur read it all day Saturday) and loved it. The horcrux in Harry was destroyed by Voldemort because Harry willingly sacrficed his life. If you're looking for help with a personal book recommendation, consult our Weekly Recommendation Thread, Suggested Reading page, or ask in r/suggestmeabook. and she obeyed one of the first rules of entertainment, no matter the medium: “always leave ’em wanting more.”. I did get tired of “sit in tent – argue – feel depressed and lost – repeat”. Or maybe just read the last one. And there’s no mention of him, or Luna, or Dean, or nearly anybody the heck else in the epilogue of Splenda. There are so many continuity errors it made my teeth hurt from grinding them. Welcome to r/HarryPotter, the place where fans from around the world can meet and discuss everything in the Harry Potter universe! He has also never read the books. Alfonso Cuaron? If there was anything shocking about the book, it was that so many characters could be redeemed by the tiny shard of goodness within them. A throw away character in this book, barely a cameo. Identical twins who have finished each other’s sentences for years. Please post only self posts or posts to a RELEVANT external link. Well, I too lined up at midnight, and managed to get the book read by Sunday, thus avoiding spoilage. As part of our commitment to that mission, the AskWomen subreddit is curated to promote respectful and on-topic discussions, and not serve as a debate subreddit. PREVIEW: Discover a burgeoning genius in Augel’s YOUNG LEONARDO, Brace yourselves: THE FALCON AND THE WINTER SOLDIER is coming. No discussion about the movies allowed. If two decades past and he was still scarred by the whole thing? /r/Relationships is a community built around helping people and the goal of providing a platform for interpersonal relationship advice between redditors. Welcome to r/HarryPotter, the place where fans from around the world can meet and discuss everything in the Harry Potter universe! If only to get Simon Pegg in a role…. You have been warned. Advertising slots are available right now for the Beat. Learning his true character through his memories was fitting. Be sorted, earn house points, take classes with our fine Hogwarts staff, debate which actor portrayed Dumbledore the best, and finally get some closure for your Post-Potter Depression. All that has certainly damaged him. Snape was never going to come out and tell Harry all of that himself. I also enjoyed the many subtle references to previous books, for instance; “For goodness sakes, Ron, are you a wizard or not?” as an allusion to Hermione forgetting how to cast fire in the first book: Nice. This subreddit is a place to dicuss theories on what may or may not have happened to the characters in the Harry Potter series, either after the books were finished, or when there is a lapse in the story. A page for describing Headscratchers: Harry Potter. Too much also happened off screen — Ginny/Neville/Luna raiding Snape’s office, Neville’s resistance, etc. I gotta re-read the last 150 pages a little more slowly…. Every time a character dies, we just kind of shrug and move on — if even that. It’s fitting. Because the wand refuses to hurt his rightful owner ? I don’t think all the Death Eaters were ready to sit down and break bread with the rest of the community. And the best thing about the epilogue…was reading that harry’s son has “severus” in his name. I go to work every day to feed them, clothe them, and give them a home. Also, I… just didn’t care. Brought to life in the imagination of J.K. Rowling, Harry Potter went on to become the most successful book series the world has ever seen.In the years since its creation, the Harry Potter brand has spawned best-selling games, toys, theme parks and the third biggest movie franchise of all-time. Harry has been damaged by so much leading up to the final battle with Voldemort. In Tolkien there’s more long term damage. This could have been a much better book had someone worked with Rowling to even it out. Did you see Children of Men? Site Wrapper – spec available on request. It felt good to me to know that even after all of that horror and tragedy, Harry’s greatest victory may be the fact that he is able to leave the horror behind him and truly heal to the point where he can lead a normal life. She is the co-author of The Secret Teachings of a Comic Book Master. He got the sword from the sorting hat, same as Harry. Instead she rounds out the series with a milqetoast, predictable saccarine ending.
Environmental Protection Department Mentorship Programme 2020, Icefuse Global Content Pack, Silk Scarves Dunnes Stores, Phfa Rental Assistance, Watson Armstrong Funeral Home, Best Pixar Characters, Crawley Council Report A Problem, Mould Release Spray Screwfix, Ggsave Font Size,